
Has the familiar pipe band competition worn itself out? Is it time to give the whole thing another look?
It’s easy to take it all for granted and settle in to the familiarity of it. We lament season after season that the eastern U.S. has been slow to produce a body of quality pipe bands to compete squarely with our counterparts in Scotland, Ireland, or even Ontario. But what if the format is as much responsible for the progress (or lack thereof) of pipe band-ing in general here in the U.S.?
The “Cut-Off” in the Winter 2006 issue of The Voice spoke of expectations. From that issue:
It is natural for us to adapt to meet whatever expectations are placed on us—whether those expectations are at work, come from family or friends, or, in this case, from competition performance. When the only venue or stage for a U.S. Highland piper is the competition boards, the expectations are not only implicit, they become the core of any preparation and education. Given this relationship, what can you expect? Poor quality piping makes a statement about the nature of the venue as much as any teaching.
One might feel we are thus “locked in” to our fate in the format we have for pipe bands. But as is evident in a variety of “supplemental” pipe band venues, bands will rise to the challenge when given it.
The Celtic Classic in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, going into its twenty-first year, has consistently provided a format that is both challenging and exhilarating. Anyone who has had the pleasure to play in a band invited to this event will speak positively about the experience. Beyond this though, the performances one hears in each of the four performances over two days is always at an extremely high level. The format this competition provides consistently requires “more” of pipe bands. And pipers and drummers in invited bands consistently find that it’s there to give and deliver.
There could be many reasons for this rise in single-contest performance standard, but what is clear is that the Celtic Classic format—an unusual break from the staid and familiar—produces results on the field. Perhaps it is time to take a cue from an event like this to inject some additional spark to American pipe bands.
The relaunched EUSPBA Pipe Band Championships provides a similar change in format and gives pipe bands a welcome change of pace. Here, there is a framework for tweaking the format and offering bands a reason to give “more.”
Just as soloists are finding a variety of new venues that demand just a wee bit more of them as performers, and bringing up the standard of play in the process, perhaps it is time to address pipe band competition as well and think about what kind of quality could result if small changes were made in format and/or venue. More premier-style events such as the EUSPBA Championships just might provide the platform to inspire more of bands in general.
Pipe band contests are the same across the circuit and provide clear boundaries for all competitors, a good thing for sure. But what is clear is that something “new and different” provides a level of interest that draws on the passion we all feel for our chosen art. It’s time to tap that passion rather than let it stagnate in routine. Routine can be comforting, but if pipe bands are to evolve and prosper, their fields of performance must demand more of them than what is expected season after season.